The notification pops up, and your heart sinks. You thought the sit went perfectly, the cats were happy, the house was spotless. But there it is, a three-star review sitting on your profile like a stain. Your mind races. You hit refresh, hoping it’s a mistake. It’s not. In a world built on trust, like the one on Trusted House Sitters, a 5-star rating is the currency, and anything less feels like a personal attack.
It’s impossible to predict how every sit will go. You can have the highest cleaning standards, communicate daily, and still find yourself on the receiving end of a review that doesn’t match your experience.
Sometimes it's a simple misunderstanding; other times, it feels entirely out of left field. So, what should I do if I get a negative review on a House sitting site? The answer isn’t to panic or fire off an angry reply. It’s to play the long game with a calm, strategic response.
Your First 24 Hours: The No-Response Rule
That fiery, defensive reply bubbling up inside you? That’s your worst enemy right now. The single most important thing to do immediately after seeing a bad review is nothing at all.
Seriously. Close the laptop. Put your phone down. Go for a walk, make a coffee, do anything but marinate in that feeling of injustice while staring at the screen.
Give it a few hours, or even a full day. You need to approach this with a clear mind, not one clouded by anger or frustration. An emotional, knee-jerk response is a massive red flag to future homeowners, often looking worse than the initial review itself.
Once you’ve cooled off, come back and read the review objectively. Try to detach from the sting and identify the core complaint. Is it about cleanliness? A miscommunication over pet care? A perceived lack of updates? Understanding their point of view, even if you believe it's inaccurate, is the first step toward crafting a response that fixes the problem instead of fueling the fire.
Crafting a Reply That Builds Trust
Your public reply is your most powerful tool. People who are serious about finding the right sitter really read the reviews and the responses. This is your chance to demonstrate your character. A mature, responsible reply can sometimes be more reassuring to a potential host than a profile with a flawless but untested record.
The Anatomy of a Perfect Response
Your goal is to come across as the calm, reasonable, and professional person someone would trust with their home and pets. Ignoring the review makes it look like you don't care. Attacking the homeowner makes you look difficult.
Follow this structure for a response that works:
Acknowledge and Thank: Start by thanking them for their feedback. This immediately de-escalates the situation. "Thank you for sharing your experience and feedback from our recent sit."
State Your Perspective Calmly: Briefly and factually address the main point without getting into a he-said-she-said battle. Avoid accusatory language. Instead of "You never told me to do that," try "There seems to have been a miscommunication regarding the watering schedule for the garden, and I apologize if it wasn't handled to your expectation."
Own It and Show Growth: This is the most crucial part. Take it as a learning experience. This shows maturity and a commitment to being a better sitter. "This has been a valuable learning experience. Moving forward, I'll be sure to create a detailed checklist with homeowners before they leave to ensure all expectations are aligned." This is far more powerful than trying to prove them wrong about factual inaccuracies in a comment section. Take it on the chin and show you've grown.
End Positively: Conclude with a polite and professional sign-off. "We truly enjoyed our time with Buster and wish you all the best."
Using an AI tool like ChatGPT can be a secret weapon here. Paste your drafted response and ask it to remove emotional language and make it sound more professional. It’s a great way to get a final polish before you post.
The Long Game: Diluting the Negative and Rebuilding Your Profile
Will one negative review tank your house-sitting career? It might have a short-term impact, but it’s rarely a fatal blow. In fact, your thoughtful response can become your biggest asset, showcasing the exact kind of problem-solving maturity homeowners look for. A House Sitting Profile that shows you can handle adversity is a strong one.
The most effective strategy to neutralize a bad review is dilution. You need to bury it with new, glowing 5-star reviews. Start actively looking for your next few house sitting opportunities. Consider shorter, local sits (How Can I Find House Sitting Near Me Using Online Services) that you can complete quickly to repopulate your profile with positive feedback.
Understanding the platform is also key. Not all House Sitting Sites are the same. It's wise to know which companies provide verified reviews for housesitting services, as this can add another layer of trust.
What to Do if a Review is Malicious
Sometimes, a review goes beyond a simple disagreement and feels genuinely malicious or retaliatory. While most platforms have tamper-proof review systems and are hesitant to remove them unless they clearly violate the terms of service (like containing private information or threats), you should still take action.
First, contact the platform's support team. Calmly explain the situation and provide any evidence you have. This creates a documented record of the issue, which is important. Even if they don't remove the review, you've officially lodged your side of the story. After that, your only recourse is the public reply. Stick to the calm, mature, and forward-looking response strategy. It remains your best defense.
Ultimately, a negative review feels like a huge deal in the moment, but it’s just a bump in the road. It’s a lesson in managing expectations and the art of communication, two of the most important skills in a sitter's toolkit.
Learn from it, respond with grace, and focus on stacking up positive experiences. The right homeowners will see your professionalism and value it.
DM us @housesittersguide if you have questions , we answer everyone!
Konrad and Caro 🐾
How soon should I respond to a negative house sitting review?
You should wait at least a few hours, or even a full day. It is crucial to respond with a calm and clear mind, not while you are feeling angry or defensive.
Is it better to ignore a bad house sitting review?
No, you should always respond. A thoughtful, mature response shows future homeowners that you are professional, engaged, and take feedback seriously. Ignoring it can be perceived as apathy.
Can I get a malicious review removed from a house sitting website?
It is very difficult, as most platforms have tamper-proof review policies. You should report it to the platform's support team to have it documented, but your primary focus should be on crafting a calm and professional public reply.
Will one bad review ruin my chances of getting future house sits?
Not necessarily. While it may have a short-term impact, a well-crafted, mature response can actually showcase your professionalism. The best way to overcome it is to get several new 5-star reviews to push it down your profile.
What is the best tone to use when replying to a negative review?
Adopt a calm, mature, and responsible tone. Acknowledge the feedback, briefly explain your perspective without making excuses, and focus on what you've learned from the experience. Avoid being defensive or emotional at all costs.
