Is House Sitting Safe? A Realistic Guide After 20 Sits

Home > Blog > House Sitting Safety

Quick Facts

Your 5-Step House Sitting Safety Checklist

Is house sitting safe? After 20 house sits across 12 countries, including three completed entirely solo, our honest answer is yes, and the number that best explains why is 98%, the share of TrustedHouseSitters sits that receive five-star reviews. This is the complete picture of what keeps that number that high, and what to do on the rare occasion something feels wrong.

If you're getting started, a 25% discount on TrustedHouseSitters is available here.

That 98% figure comes from over 11,500 active listings worldwide. That means only a small fraction produce a review below five stars, and that below-five category includes four stars, three stars, all the way down. The chances of a genuinely bad experience are rare. Not impossible, but far smaller than the fear keeping most people from trying.

What makes this stat more meaningful in 2026 is the double-blind review system THS and other platform use. Neither homeowner nor sitter can see the other's review until both have submitted, or until the 14-day window closes.

This removes the single biggest distortion in any review system: the fear of retaliation. A sitter can now leave an honest account of a difficult sit without worrying the homeowner will read it and respond vindictively before writing their own. The 98% figure reflects genuine satisfaction, not diplomatic silence.

Platform Safety Comparison: Why the Platform You Choose Is Your First Line of Defence

Not all house sitting platforms offer the same level of protection. Before anything else, the platform itself determines the baseline safety of every interaction you have.

Anyone willing to pay $129 (£99) or more per year for platform access is demonstrating commitment. They are not anonymous. Their ID is verified. Their name is tied to every interaction they have, building a public record that follows them permanently. They cannot delete their history and start fresh the way someone can in a Facebook group.

Platforms actively ban accounts that abuse the system. The review mechanism surfaces bad actors quickly. Caro came across a listing recently with a review history that told a remarkable story. A sitter had her bag raided by the homeowner's daughter, who stole makeup while the sitter was in the house.

The homeowner, on discovering this, arranged for everything to be returned, offered compensation, and posted a public review explaining what had happened and apologising to future sitters. The system worked exactly as it should: the incident was documented, accountability was public, and future sitters had the full picture. That story increased our confidence in the platform rather than reducing it, and it's worth reading in full in our dedicated guide on what to do if someone steals from you during a house sit, which covers the step-by-step response if this ever happens to you.

For a full breakdown of exactly what each platform verifies, our background checks guide covers what happens behind the scenes on every major platform.

The Video Call Is Your Most Important Safety Check

We have never accepted a sit without a video call. Not once. And if we do not feel comfortable during that call, we do not proceed, regardless of how good the listing looks.

The video call tells you things a listing cannot. You see how the homeowner communicates, whether they are relaxed or evasive, how they talk about their animals, whether the home in the background matches the photos. In our experience the call predicts the sit almost perfectly. If you feel comfortable during it, you will almost certainly feel comfortable during the sit. If something feels off, it will not improve when you arrive.

We don't watch for specific tells during a call, camera angles, background details, that sort of thing. What we actually pay attention to is simpler: how the conversation feels. If someone is trying to hide or misrepresent something, it tends to surface as a kind of awkwardness in how they talk, not a specific lie you can point to. It's not a perfectly reliable signal, but we'd rather pass on a sit because of a feeling that turns out to be wrong than find out later we should have listened to it.

That instinct got properly tested once, applying for a sit in Bratislava. My connection dropped right as the video call was starting, a genuine technical accident, nothing more. We messaged the homeowner within minutes to explain, but by then she was already annoyed, and told us plainly she didn't want us to come to the house anymore.

Accidents happen to everyone, and how someone reacts to a small, understandable one tells you a great deal about how they'd react to something bigger during an actual sit. We didn't push back or try to salvage it. We moved on, and the sit we found instead worked out better than Bratislava likely would have. Sometimes the video call teaches you something before it's even properly started. Our red flags guide covers more warning signs like this one, on both sides of the arrangement.

When we were in conversation with a different homeowner who had a great dog, a pool, and an outdoor shower but communicated strangely and could never commit to firm dates, we already had the Ostuni sit virtually confirmed. We informed him we had found another sit and moved on before finalising Ostuni. That decision cost us nothing. Ostuni turned out to be a great experience. The principle held: do not force yourself into a sit because the listing looks good on paper.

Available listings keep growing across most major platforms, so the pool only gets larger. There is no sit worth overriding your instinct for. Our house sitting video call guide covers the exact questions we ask a homeowner and what the answers tell us.

Basic Habits Matter More Than Gadgets

People ask us this constantly, personal alarms, GPS trackers, smart locks, monitoring apps. Our honest answer, after 20 sits, is that we use almost none of it, and we don't think most sitters need to either.

What we do instead is simple, ordinary stuff, the same habits anyone builds from years of living in their own home. We lock the door behind us. We close windows at night. If a property has an alarm, we use it, though so far we've never had a sit that required entering a code every single time we came and went. None of this is house-sitting-specific knowledge.

It's just the normal discipline of living somewhere, transferred from your own home into someone else's. That's part of what makes house sitting genuinely comfortable after enough sits, the skills you already have carry over directly.

The deeper reason we don't feel the need for more than that: a home that looks lived in is rarely targeted in the first place. People looking for an easy target tend to go after empty holiday homes, not houses with lights on, cars in the driveway, and someone clearly living there.

We've never had anyone attempt to break in or even approach a property we were staying at, across every single sit. Genuinely, after enough of them, it stops feeling like a security assignment and starts feeling exactly like living in your own home.

There's an honest comparison worth making here too. We're actually more on edge when we're campervanning between sits than we ever are during an actual sit. A van parked on a street is a far more obvious, opportunistic target than a house that's clearly occupied. If anything, house sitting has made us feel safer than the travel style that surrounds it. Our campervan vs house sitting comparison covers this hybrid lifestyle in more depth. The one thing we do carry, in either situation, is a GPS tracker kept with our own belongings, a general travel precaution rather than a house-sitting-specific one.

Homeowners choosing to invite a stranger into their home also tend to already live somewhere reasonably safe, they wouldn't be comfortable doing it otherwise. That filtering happens before you even apply.

The Kefalonia Lesson: When to Stay and When to Leave

The Kefalonia sit was the closest we have come to genuinely considering leaving mid-sit. The listing showed one dog and one cat. The reality was nine cats, several with fleas, and two weeks of bites that accumulated into a low-level misery that is harder to describe than it sounds.

It was not dramatic. Nobody was in danger. But flea bites affect your mind more than your skin. You begin to feel like something is on you constantly. You scratch at nothing. You stop sleeping properly. Over two weeks that becomes genuinely wearing.

We stayed. The island and the dog made it worth it. But there were days when we discussed leaving seriously.

The lesson is about gradation. People tolerate slightly uncomfortable situations because the discomfort feels manageable. A small patch of mould is liveable. A wall covered in it prompts immediate action. Both are health risks. Only one registers as urgent.

The practical principle: if a sit has a problem that is worsening, escalate your response before it reaches the point where leaving feels like the only option. The flea situation in Kefalonia was raised with the homeowner as soon as we noticed it. She arranged treatment immediately. Early communication gives problems a chance to be solved. Silence lets them compound.

If a sit has become genuinely untenable, leaving is a valid choice. Our cancellation guide covers exactly how to handle that. And if you arrive to find the property in poor condition, document it immediately, our what not to do when house sitting guide covers how to handle a difficult arrival without making the situation worse.

Communication Is Its Own Safety Net

One habit has mattered more for our peace of mind, and the homeowner's, than any device could. During a serious storm on that same Kefalonia sit, water started coming in through a window. We took a photo and sent it straight to the homeowners rather than waiting to see how it played out. They told us it was normal for that property in bad weather, and that was the end of it, no drama, no scare, just information shared in the moment.

That's the actual value of communicating early: it means nothing ever becomes a surprise later, for either side. If something had gotten worse, they'd have already known it started, rather than wondering what we did or didn't do. Sharing information as it happens, whether it turns out to matter or not, protects the sit and protects you.

We apply a version of the same principle with our own families, not a rigid check-in schedule, nothing like "call by this time or we worry." We just let our families know roughly where we are and what we're doing, especially whenever we're heading into a new country. It's a simple habit, not a safety protocol, but it means if anything ever did happen, someone would already know where to start looking. Being part of a couple adds another layer here too, there are always two of us paying attention, which we recognise is a genuine advantage a solo sitter doesn't automatically have.

Local knowledge, the nearest hospital, the nearest police station, tends to come up naturally rather than requiring separate research. Most sits involve at least one overnight overlap with the homeowner before they leave, occasionally two, and that handover conversation is usually where anything practical like that gets covered, alongside everything else about the home. We've never actually needed any of it. In 20 sits, we've never had to call the police once. Genuinely unfortunate things do happen in this world, but they're rare enough that we don't spend energy bracing for them, we focus on the very good odds instead.

Solo Female House Sitting

We wrote a full, dedicated guide on this specifically because it deserves more room than a section here can give it, covering the real risks, a proper comparison against other solo travel styles, and the exact precautions worth taking. Read our complete solo female house sitting safety guide for the full picture. Caro has never sat completely alone, so that guide is written with the honest framing of an outside but genuinely informed perspective, not false lived experience.

Emergency Preparedness: Slow Everything Down

I spent years as a qualified lifeguard and outdoor instructor with advanced first aid certification. The single most useful thing I was ever taught has nothing to do with specific techniques. It is this: when something goes wrong, slow down.

The image my instructor used was rolling a cigarette, a deliberate, focused, unhurried action. Those few seconds of conscious deceleration stop the panic reflex that makes people skip steps and worsen situations. When you panic, you jump to conclusions. Slowing down gives you the gap between stimulus and response where good judgement lives.

When Caro broke a glass at a sit, the sequence was: hold the dog back, put shoes on, take a photo, get the dustpan, clean up, message the homeowners with an apology. Each step in order, nothing rushed, nobody hurt. Secure the situation first. Communicate once you have something useful to say.

The order in any genuine emergency: remove yourself and the pets from danger, secure the home, contact emergency services if needed, contact the homeowner. Then work through everything step by step.

We used the THS 24/7 vet line in Bochum when one of the cats developed a swollen paw. Within minutes we had a remote assessment, a diagnosis of a bee sting, and a care plan. By the time the homeowner responded to our message we had already handled it. That is what good emergency preparedness looks like in practice, and it is one of the reasons the Standard or Premium THS plan is worth the cost difference. Our TrustedHouseSitters review covers the full plan comparison.

Insurance: Is It Necessary?

This comes up constantly, and it deserves more room than we can give it here. We carry multiple policies ourselves across our 20 sits, and what actually matters more than whether you have insurance is understanding exactly what each platform does and doesn't cover before you rely on it. Our two dedicated guides cover this properly: do house sitters need insurance walks through our honest answer and what we personally carry, and our full platform-by-platform insurance breakdown covers exactly what THS, Nomador, and six other platforms actually cover in their terms.

Is House Sitting a Scam?

We get this question constantly on Instagram, is it actually real, is it legit, is it a scam. We can say plainly: no, it is not a scam, and if you go through the platforms we recommend, you are far more likely to have an incredible experience than a bad one.

That doesn't mean nothing ever goes wrong. There are homeowners who take advantage of sitters, expecting far more work than the exchange was ever meant to involve, or, on rare occasion, quietly hoping for payment on top of free accommodation.

That isn't the model house sitting is built on, and it's a genuinely different problem from the sit itself being fraudulent. Our full guide to spotting house sitting scams covers fake listings, payment red flags, and what we personally watch for on every sit. The core purpose of this entire site is exactly this: helping people get the most out of house sitting safely, not just telling them it's safe and leaving it there.

Digital Safety: A Simple Rule

Ask the homeowner before posting anything about their property or pets on social media or a blog. It is their home and their animals. Most are happy for pet photos. Some prefer the property's location to remain private. The conversation takes ten seconds and removes any ambiguity. We ask this as standard now, and homeowners consistently appreciate being asked rather than finding out afterwards.

The broader principle: you do not need to broadcast your real-time location while sitting. Posting that you are in a specific home, in a specific city, on a specific date is unnecessary detail. Share the experience. Protect the specifics.

Is House Sitting Safe?

After 20 sits, the honest answer is yes. The 98% five-star figure reflects a community built around reputation, where the incentive to behave well is structural and permanent. Both homeowners and sitters have everything to lose from a bad review and everything to gain from a good one.

Use the video call as your primary filter. Walk away from anything that does not feel right. Build a financial buffer into your trip budget. Stay calm when the unexpected happens. Communicate early rather than waiting for a problem to grow. Ask before you post. And remember that with thousands of sits available at any moment, there is no sit worth compromising your safety for.

Caro and I have completed 20 house sits across 12 countries, driven 19,000km across Europe in our 1998 VW T4, and saved over $26,500 in accommodation costs over three years of house sitting. DM us @housesittersguide if you have questions, we answer everyone.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Is house sitting safe?

  Yes. After 20 sits across 12 countries, our honest answer is yes. The platform's 98% five-star review rate, mandatory ID verification, and a proper video call before every sit are what actually keep it that way. This isn't blind optimism, it's a system built on accountability that works.

• Is house sitting safe for solo females?

  Yes, with the right preparation, and it deserves a full answer rather than a quick one. Our dedicated solo female house sitting safety guide covers the complete picture, including how it compares to other solo travel styles.

• Do house sitters need safety gadgets like personal alarms or GPS trackers?

  Not usually. We've never had an attempted break-in or approach across 20 sits, and a home that looks lived in is rarely targeted in the first place. We carry a hidden GPS tracker with our own belongings as a general travel precaution, but nothing beyond ordinary lock-and-window habits.

• What's a real example of a red flag showing up on a video call?

  Not a lie or a deception, but a reaction. My connection genuinely dropped during a call for a sit in Bratislava, and the homeowner was annoyed enough afterward to say she no longer wanted us to come. How someone reacts to a small, honest accident often tells you more than anything they say during a smooth call.

• What are the red flags for house sitting?

  A homeowner who avoids or repeatedly reschedules the video call. Communication that is evasive, overly familiar, or aggressive. A listing where the photos do not match what you see on the call. Vague answers about pet health, property condition, or dates. Pressure to confirm quickly before you have had time to think. Any one of these warrants a closer look. More than one warrants walking away.

• Is house sitting a scam?

  No. It's a genuine exchange model used by thousands of people, us included, across 20 sits. Bad individual actors exist, as they do anywhere, but the core model is legitimate. Our full scams guide covers exactly what to watch for.

• Do house sitters need insurance?

  It's worth understanding rather than assuming either way. Our dedicated insurance guide covers what we personally carry and why, and our platform insurance breakdown covers exactly what each platform's terms actually promise.

• How do I handle an emergency during a house sit?

  Slow down first. Remove yourself and the pets from immediate danger, secure the property, then contact emergency services if needed. Contact the homeowner once the situation is under control, you will have something more useful to say. If you are on THS Standard or Premium, the 24/7 vet line handles pet health emergencies remotely at any hour.

• What should I do if I feel unsafe during a house sit?

  Leave. Your safety comes before the sit, the review, and any obligation you feel toward the homeowner. Document the situation, contact THS support, and remove yourself from the property. If there is immediate danger, contact local emergency services first.

Related Guides