How to Decline a House Sitter Kindly (With Wording You Can Copy)

Home > Blog > How to Decline a House Sitter

Quick Facts

Declining a house sitter badly is usually not cruelty, it is silence. Tell them within 24 to 48 hours, keep it short, and you do not owe a reason. Name real future dates if you would have them back. One line is enough, and it costs you nothing.

Before anything else, the thing we would want you to know. Our book Travel More for Less covers the whole exchange from the sitter's side, including how to apply and how to read a listing, and it is the single most useful thing we have written on any of this. This page is the other direction: what happens when you are the one holding the applications.

Caro and I have been the sitter in this conversation 20 times across 12 countries. We have been turned down well, turned down badly, and far more often than either, simply not answered at all. That last one is the reason this page exists.

For most of Europe we point sitters at TrustedHouseSitters first, and our 25% discount link is there for anyone you send their way. None of what follows depends on which platform you use.

If your problem is the opposite one, a listing that nobody is applying for at all, why homeowners are not getting applications is the page you want instead.

Many Homeowners Say Nothing, And That Is The Whole Problem

We have applied for sits and heard nothing back. Not a no, not a maybe, just nothing, ever. The listing stays open, the dates sit there, and you have no idea whether to keep looking or wait.

I think that is genuinely rude, and I do not think it takes much to fix. Someone read your listing carefully, wrote you a message specifically about your home and your animals, and waited. If they are new to this, the wait matters even more. Two lines in return is basic courtesy.

I also understand why it happens. People are busy. They forget. They are hunting for the right person rather than managing a group of applicants, and replying to everyone feels like admin they never signed up for. Some homeowners probably never saw it as an exchange at all.

None of that is malicious and none of it makes them bad people. It just means the sitter is left in the dark, and that is the part worth changing.

The 24 To 48 Hour Rule

The date matters. If the sit is months away you have time, and nobody is disadvantaged by a slower answer. If it is close, they need to know today.

Outside those extremes, a holding message within 24 to 48 hours is more than enough. It does not have to be a decision: *we are still waiting for all the applicants to come through, and once they have we will let you know and organise a conversation.* That keeps everyone on the same page and takes you fifteen seconds.

Here is why it matters more than it looks. A sitter waiting on your answer cannot plan. If they get the sit, they have a home for those dates. If they do not, they need to keep applying. Silence puts them in a position where they can neither commit nor move on, which is genuinely worse than a no.

Turn it around for a second. If a sitter told you they wanted a call and then went quiet for two days, how would that feel? It would feel like being messed about. It is an equal exchange, so the standard should be equal too. Our timeline for working through applicants covers how long to take and what to say while you decide. Once you have started talking to people, what to cover on the video call is the other half of doing this well.

You Do Not Owe A Reason, But You Do Owe A Reply

This is the bit homeowners most often get wrong in their own heads, and it stops them writing anything at all.

You do not owe an explanation. You do not have to justify not choosing someone, and you do not have to list what was wrong with them. *Sorry, we have gone with someone else this time* is a complete, polite, finished answer.

If they ask why, that is different. Then you can give them something factual, and I would. When we applied for a beautiful home in Switzerland and asked what we could have done better, the homeowner told us he required seven five-star reviews minimum. It stung a little, because we had five and felt confident. But it was useful, it was true, and it told us exactly what to do next.

You are not obliged to give that. But if you are willing, it is worth far more to the sitter than a compliment would be.

Wording You Can Copy

The reason people decline badly is not unkindness. It is that they do not know what to write, so they write nothing. Here is something for each version of the conversation. Change the details, keep the shape. If you are still deciding who to shortlist, the red flags worth checking are quicker to spot than most homeowners expect.

Before the video call

After the video call

Keeping the door open

This is the version worth learning, and it is the one homeowners most often skip. If you would happily have someone back, say so, and give them something real to hold.

We have gone with someone else because we spoke to them first, but we would love to have you another time. Our next dates are likely [dates]. If you are free, please do apply.

Naming actual dates is what makes this work. A vague "keep in touch" reads as a brush-off, and nobody believes it.

We receive this version often, and it is the one that leaves you feeling fine about a no. It is also how a one-off sit turns into a sitter who comes back every year.

When the sitter asks why

Answer once, factually, and do not pad it.

We wanted someone with more reviews for this particular home

is a fair answer.

I needed seven five-star reviews minimum is a fair answer.

What is not fair is inventing a criticism to justify a preference you simply had.

Cancelling a sitter you have already confirmed

This is a different conversation and it needs to happen faster and more directly, because they may already have flights.

Say it plainly, apologise once, and lead with the practical.

We have to cancel your sit for [dates]. I am sorry, I know that is short notice. Please let me know what you have already booked and what can be changed, and we will work out the costs.

Then use the platform's cancellation process rather than handling it privately, because that is what protects you both. If they respond badly, what to do when a sitter bails covers the worst version. Our cancellation guide covers the mechanics on each platform.

Why Homeowners Go Quiet

I have sat in 20 homes, which means I have watched 20 homeowners do this. My honest read is that it comes down to three things.

They are busy, and it stops feeling like an exchange. Replying to five applicants feels like unpaid admin. Replying to the one you chose feels like progress. So the rest get dropped.

They are afraid of being unkind. Some homeowners think saying nothing is gentler than saying no. It is the opposite. A polite no takes one line. Silence leaves someone checking their inbox for a week.

Nobody told them what to write. This is the one that is easy to fix, which is why the wording above exists.

There is also a fourth reason that is completely legitimate: the sitter was clearly wrong for the home. Even then, one line costs you nothing. If you are still choosing between applicants, our guide to how much notice you need is worth reading before you rush a decision.

The Two Rejections That Stayed With Us

We missed a video call by a few minutes once and apologised in a message straight away. The homeowner was furious and would not budge, so that was that. I have no complaint about it. It is her home and her judgement, and it worked out fine for us in the end because we needed to go back anyway.

The other one was Switzerland, a genuinely stunning house, after five five-star sits in a row. We were proud of that record and confident. The answer was seven reviews minimum. That one stung for a day, and then it just told us what to do next, which was a few more sits.

Both of those are fine. What is not fine is the sit we applied for and never heard about again.

The Golden Rule That Settles It

I look at house sitting the way I try to treat everything. Do to others as you would have them do to you. If you would not want to be left waiting after writing a careful message about someone's home, do not leave someone waiting.

That is genuinely the whole argument, and it is the same standard we hold sitters to in what makes a sit a fair exchange. Every awkward decline becomes easy once you decide that the person on the other end is a guest you invited to take part, not an application to be processed.

The more respect you show to the people who apply, the more you get back. The sitters we keep returning to are the ones whose homeowners treated us like people, and we remember every single one.

Conclusion

Declining a house sitter kindly is four things. Reply within 24 to 48 hours, even if it is only to buy time. Keep the message short and do not invent reasons. If you would have them back, say so and give them real dates. And use the platform's process if you are cancelling someone already confirmed.

We have completed 20 house sits across 12 countries, driven 19,000km across Europe in our 1998 VW T4, and saved over $26,500 in accommodation costs over three years of house sitting. We have been turned down a lot in that time, and the good ones all looked like the wording above. The standard we were being measured against is the one in what makes a professional house sitter.

If you want the whole thing from the other side, it is in our book Travel More for Less.

DM us @housesittersguide, we answer everyone.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Do I owe a house sitter a reason for declining?

  No, and asking yourself that question is usually what causes the silence. "Sorry, we have gone with someone else this time" is a complete answer. If they ask why, give them something factual if you are willing, but you are not obliged to.

• How long should I take to respond to a house sitter?

  A holding message within 24 to 48 hours, and a decision as soon as you have one. If the sit is months away you have more room. If it is close, they need an answer today, because they cannot plan until they have one.

• Is it rude to decline a house sitter by message?

  No, it is the decent thing to do. A short message is kinder than silence. Going quiet leaves someone checking their inbox and unable to decide whether to keep applying elsewhere.

• What do I say if I want to keep the sitter for next time?

  Say you went with someone else because you spoke to them first, and name your real future dates. Actual dates are what make it credible. "Keep in touch" reads as a brush-off and nobody believes it.

• Should I decline by message or just let the listing close?

  Message them either way, and close the listing so it is visibly finished. Leaving it open with no reply is the version sitters find hardest, because they cannot tell whether they are still in the running.

• What if I have to cancel a sitter I already confirmed?

  Tell them fast, apologise once, and lead with the practical. Ask what they have already booked, say you will work out the costs, and use the platform’s cancellation process rather than settling it privately.

Related Guides