Can Dogs Eat Pumpkin? The Puree, Not the Pie

Home > Blog > Can Dogs Eat Pumpkin? The Puree, Not the Pie

Quick Facts

This is our own research, not veterinary advice. For nearly every food there are many sources, and they do not always agree with each other. We check each claim against the veterinary and poison control sources, and we say plainly where they disagree. Even so, if you are in any doubt, contact a vet and do your own research before you feed anything to an animal in your care.

Plain pumpkin is safe for dogs and genuinely useful, because the fibre is the point. A spoonful mixed into a meal is the standard home remedy for a loose stool, and most dogs will eat it without noticing. The trap is pumpkin pie filling, which is a different food with sugar, spices and sometimes xylitol in it. Buy 100% pumpkin and read the tin.

I have never given pumpkin to a dog because of a bad stomach. I gave it because dogs love it, in the same way they love a carrot. Small pieces, handed over one at a time, and they chew on it and enjoy it. The reputation it has as a remedy is real and worth knowing about, but it is not why it was ever in my kitchen.

It is also the clearest example on this site of a whole food and a manufactured version being completely different propositions. The tin of puree and the tin of pie filling look almost identical, which is exactly why the filling gets its own section.

If you are interested in getting into house sitting, our book Travel More for Less puts the whole process in one place: clear, step by step guidance from your first questions to your first confirmed sit, and the reviews that open the door to the next one.

Can Dogs Eat Pumpkin? Yes, Plain and Nothing Else

Pumpkin is safe for dogs, and it does not appear on any poison control avoid list. The version that is good for them is plain cooked pumpkin or a tin of 100% pumpkin puree with nothing added.

That is the whole specification: pumpkin, and nothing but pumpkin. If the tin has a list of ingredients beyond pumpkin, it is a different product and a different answer.

Raw pumpkin is fine too, though there is no reason to bother. The flesh is hard and the only real risk is a dog trying to get through the skin, which is tough enough to be a chewing problem rather than a food one.

The Pie Filling Is a Different Food

This is the part that matters most, because pumpkin pie filling is what most households actually have in the cupboard, and it is not the same thing as a tin of puree.

Pie filling brings sugar, and it brings a spice blend that includes nutmeg and cloves. Nutmeg in quantity is a genuine problem for dogs, and cloves are not something to feed them either. Some brands also carry xylitol, the sweetener that is lethal to dogs in very small amounts.

Pumpkin pie itself is the same story with pastry and cream on top. Nothing about it is a dog treat, and the pumpkin is the innocent ingredient in the middle.

The test takes five seconds. Turn the tin around and read the ingredients. One word, pumpkin, means yes. A list means no.

If the wrong tin has already been opened, what to do when a pet eats something dangerous covers the sequence, and xylitol is the ingredient there that would make it urgent rather than a wait and see.

Fibre, and Why It Helps Both Ways

The reason pumpkin has a reputation beyond a treat is fibre. It is the standard thing people reach for when a dog has a loose stool, and it is also given for the opposite problem, which sounds like a contradiction and is not.

With constipation, the fibre adds bulk and moisture to the stool, which helps it pass. With a loose stool, the same fibre absorbs water and firms things up. It is one ingredient doing two different jobs depending on what the gut needs, which is why the same tin gets recommended for both.

The ceiling matters here. Too much pumpkin causes diarrhoea rather than curing it, because you have added more fibre than the gut can process. A spoonful is a remedy. Half a tin is a mistake.

How Much Pumpkin

Cooked pumpkin is about 20 kcal per 100 g, so the calorie cost is almost nothing. That is not the limit. The limit is fibre and how much a dog's gut can take at once.

No source publishes a portion by dog size, so the practical answer is a tablespoon or two rather than a bowl, once or twice a day, mixed into the normal food rather than given on its own.

Those calorie figures are our arithmetic on the published energy value. The useful way to judge it is by the spoon rather than the scale: a couple of tablespoons is a remedy, and anything close to a cup is a different experiment.

Pumpkin Seeds and Pumpkin Spice

Pumpkin seeds are fine in small amounts, as long as they are plain and unsalted. The shells are tough, so a handful of whole seeds is more chewing than most dogs need, and salted or roasted seeds bring the salt problem instead.

Pumpkin spice is a blend made for people. It is mostly cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves and allspice, and nutmeg is the one to care about. A dusting is not a crisis for a large dog, but there is no reason to put it in a dog bowl, and a small dog is a different calculation from a large one.

Pumpkin seed oil and pumpkin powder sold as supplements are a third category again. They are not dangerous, but they are a product rather than a food, and the evidence for most of the claims attached to them is thin.

On a Sit: The Tin in the Cupboard

Pumpkin is the single most useful thing an owner can leave in the cupboard for a sit, and it is worth knowing where it is before you need it rather than during a 2am clean-up.

It is worth asking about at handover, along with the other practical questions. If there is a dog with a sensitive stomach, the owner usually has a preferred brand and a portion they have already worked out, and that is better than any guess. My own use is the simpler one: a few small pieces as something to chew on.

The one thing not to do is substitute. If the cupboard has pie filling and no puree, the answer is not to use the pie filling. It is to ring the owner or leave it alone, because the difference between the two tins is the difference between a remedy and a problem.

The wider habit is asking rather than improvising, and the full pre-sit question list is worth working from.

Where This Research Comes From

The sources behind this page:

Conclusion

Pumpkin is safe, useful, and one of the few things on this list that earns a permanent place in the cupboard. Plain puree, a spoonful at a time, is the whole method.

The only mistake to make is grabbing the wrong tin. Read the label, and if it has more than one ingredient, put it back.

Caro and I have completed 20 house sits across 12 countries, driven 19,000km across Europe in our 1998 VW T4, and saved over $26,500 in accommodation costs over three years of house sitting.

DM us @housesittersguide, we answer everyone.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Can dogs eat pumpkin?

  Yes, plain cooked pumpkin or a tin of 100% puree. Pumpkin is not on any poison control avoid list, and the fibre is what makes it useful.

• Can dogs eat pumpkin pie filling?

  No. Pie filling contains sugar and a spice blend that includes nutmeg and cloves, and some brands add xylitol. The tin of puree and the tin of filling look almost identical, so read the ingredients.

• Does pumpkin help a dog with diarrhoea?

  It is the standard home remedy, and the fibre absorbs water and firms the stool. Keep it to a spoonful or two, because too much fibre causes diarrhoea rather than curing it.

• How much pumpkin can a dog have?

  A tablespoon or two mixed into a meal, once or twice a day. No source publishes a portion by dog size, so judge it by the spoon rather than the scale.

• Can dogs eat pumpkin seeds?

  Yes, in small amounts, as long as they are plain and unsalted. The shells are tough to chew, so a handful of whole seeds is more work than most dogs need.

• Is pumpkin spice safe for dogs?

  The blend is made for people and contains nutmeg, which is a genuine problem in quantity. A dusting is unlikely to hurt a large dog, but there is no reason to add it to a dog bowl.

• Can cats eat pumpkin?

  Plain pumpkin is safe for cats on the same terms, and the fibre logic is the same. Keep it to a small spoonful, and use plain puree rather than filling.

Related Guides