Can Dogs Eat Broccoli? Yes, and the Toxicity Claim Is Wrong

|

9

  min read

This article contains affiliate links. If you sign up through our links we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Home > Blog > Can Dogs Eat Broccoli? Yes, and the Toxicity Claim Is Wrong

Quick Facts

QuestionAnswer
Can dogs eat broccoli?Yes, raw or cooked, and plain either way
Is it toxic?No. The compound behind the claim causes gas rather than poisoning
The stalksThe real risk. Hard enough to choke on, so cut them small
How muchA few florets. It works best as a training treat
PuppiesBetter avoided. It is a lot of fibre for a small gut
Cooking itPlain, with no butter, oil or salt
Not publishedA quantity at which the isothiocyanates would matter

This is our own research, not veterinary advice. For nearly every food there are many sources, and they do not always agree with each other. We check each claim against the veterinary and poison control sources, and we say plainly where they disagree. Even so, if you are in any doubt, contact a vet and do your own research before you feed anything to an animal in your care.

Broccoli is safe for dogs, and the claim that it is toxic is wrong. The isothiocyanates in it are real compounds, and what they do is cause gas and a bit of stomach irritation rather than poison anything. Cut the stalks into small pieces, keep it to a few florets, and it is one of the better low-calorie training treats there is.

Broccoli is not something I have ever fed a dog. I have watched plenty of videos of other people doing it, and what always strikes me is how gently the dog takes it and how long it spends working through one piece. It is also the vegetable with the most persistent bad reputation online, which is worth clearing up.

The short version is that broccoli is a brassica, brassicas contain sulphur compounds, and those compounds do something that sounds alarming in a headline and turns out to be gas.

If you are interested in getting into house sitting, our book Travel More for Less puts the whole process in one place: clear, step by step guidance from your first questions to your first confirmed sit, and the reviews that open the door to the next one.

Can Dogs Eat Broccoli? Yes, Raw or Cooked

Can dogs eat broccoli infographic: not toxic, isothiocyanates cause gas rather than poisoning, cut the stalks small

Broccoli is safe for dogs both ways. Raw is fine and holds its crunch, which some dogs prefer. Cooked is fine as long as it is plain, with no butter, oil, salt or seasoning.

It is not on any poison control avoid list, and it is a common ingredient in commercial dog food. The vitamins and fibre are real, though the amounts in a few florets are small enough that they are not the reason to give it.

The reason to give it is that it is a low-calorie treat a dog has to work at, which makes it useful in training and useful for a dog that is watching its weight.

The Toxicity Claim, and What Is Actually True

There is a claim circulating that broccoli is toxic to dogs because of isothiocyanates. There is a real compound behind it and there is a real effect, and neither of them is poisoning.

Isothiocyanates are sulphur compounds that occur naturally in brassicas, which is the family that includes broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, kale and Brussels sprouts. In broccoli they are concentrated in the florets. The same compounds are the reason brassicas have a reputation for being good for people, and they are the reason a dog that eats a lot of them will be gassy.

Fresh broccoli florets on a wooden chopping board

Gas and stomach irritation is the effect, and it is a mild one. A dog that eats a whole head of broccoli will probably have loose stool and a bad evening, and it will not have been poisoned. The difference between a vegetable that gives a dog wind and a vegetable that is toxic is the difference between discomfort and harm, and broccoli is firmly in the first category.

What nobody publishes is a quantity at which the compounds would matter. Since the effect is gas, the useful limit is not chemical at all. It is the amount of fibre a gut can handle, and that is a much lower number and a much simpler question.

A dog that has eaten a whole head is uncomfortable rather than in danger, which is a different response from something that genuinely is an emergency.

The Stalks

The stalk is the part with a genuine risk, and it is a physical one. A piece of raw broccoli stalk is firm and roughly cylindrical, which is the shape that can lodge in a small dog's throat. The florets are soft by comparison and rarely a problem.

So cut the stalk small, or leave it out. A stalk chopped into short batons is fine. A whole stalk handed to a terrier is a choking risk, and it is the kind of thing that happens because nobody thought about the shape.

Cooking softens the stalk enough to remove most of the concern, which is one reason a steamed floret is easier than a raw one.

How Much Broccoli

How much broccoli a dog can have, showing one floret, three florets and a large handful

Broccoli is about 34 kcal per 100 g, which makes it one of the lightest things you can hand a dog. That is what makes it a good training treat rather than a sometimes food.

Treats should stay under about 10% of a dog's daily calorie intake, which is the standard most vets and the literature give. The published portions run from one or two small pieces for a small dog up to a large handful for a very large one.

PortionWeightCalories
One floretabout 15 gabout 5 kcal
Three floretsabout 45 gabout 15 kcal
A large handfulabout 80 gabout 27 kcal

Those calorie figures are our arithmetic on the published energy value. The thing to watch is not the calories, it is the gas. A dog that has had a handful of broccoli at training will let you know about it later.

Puppies, and Why the Advice Is Different

The published guidance is to avoid broccoli for puppies, and the reason is fibre rather than anything in the broccoli. A puppy has a small gut and a diet that needs to be tightly balanced, and filling it with bulky vegetables is the wrong trade.

It is also a choking risk in a way it is not for an adult, because a puppy's mouth is small and it is still learning to chew. If you want a training treat for a puppy, something soft and small is a better answer.

On a Sit: The Training Treat

A dog sitting on a kitchen floor hoping for food

On a sit, broccoli would earn its place for a specific job. If a dog is overweight, or on a diet the owner is serious about, broccoli is a treat you could hand out twenty of without doing any damage. That is not true of most things a dog will actually work for.

It is also useful with a dog that is bored rather than hungry. A few florets to chase around a kitchen floor is a game, and a game is often what a restless dog actually wanted.

The thing to check first is whether the owner has a view on vegetables, because plenty do. And it is worth keeping to florets on a sit rather than stalks, because a choking incident is the last thing anybody wants to explain.

That check is part of the pre-sit question list rather than something to work out on the day.

The wider list of foods we have checked is on our page on what you can feed a pet.

Where This Research Comes From

The sources behind this page:

Conclusion

Broccoli is safe, it is cheap, and it is one of the few treats you can be generous with. The toxicity claim is a misreading of a real compound doing a mild job.

Cut the stalks small, keep it to a few florets, and expect some gas. That is the whole page.

Caro and I have completed 21 house sits across 12 countries, driven 41,000km across Australia and Europe in our 1998 VW T4, and saved over $44,000 in accommodation costs since April 2023.

DM us @housesittersguide, we answer everyone.

Konrad and Caro in France

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Can dogs eat broccoli?

    Yes, raw or cooked, as long as it is plain. It is not on any poison control avoid list and it is a common ingredient in dog food.

  • Is broccoli toxic to dogs?

    No. Isothiocyanates are real compounds in broccoli, and what they cause is gas and stomach irritation rather than poisoning. The claim gets repeated because the compounds are real, not because the toxicity is.

  • Can dogs eat broccoli stalks?

    Yes, but cut them small. A raw stalk is firm and cylindrical, which is a shape that can lodge in a small dog's throat. Short batons are fine, and cooking softens it further.

  • How much broccoli can a dog have?

    A few florets is plenty. The published portions run from one or two small pieces for a small dog up to a large handful for a very large one, and the limit is fibre rather than anything chemical.

  • Can puppies eat broccoli?

    The guidance is to avoid it, because a puppy needs a tightly balanced diet and broccoli is a lot of bulk for a small gut. It is also a bigger choking risk at that size.

  • Does broccoli give dogs gas?

    Yes. The sulphur compounds in brassicas are the reason, and a dog that eats a lot of broccoli will be windy. That is the realistic consequence, not poisoning.

  • Can cats eat broccoli?

    It is not toxic to cats, and small plain pieces are fine. Cats are obligate carnivores and do not need vegetables, so it is a taste experience rather than a contribution.

💰 Discounts for House Sitting Sites

PlatformRegionDiscountAction
TrustedHouseSittersGlobal30% OFFApplies automatically
Aussie House SittersAustralia15% OFFUse Code: HSG15
House Sitters UKUnited Kingdom15% OFFUse Code: HSG15
House Sitters CanadaCanada15% OFFUse Code: HSG15
Kiwi House SittersNew Zealand15% OFFUse Code: HSG15
House Sitters AmericaUnited States15% OFFUse Code: HSG15
MindaHome AUAustralia10% OFFUse Code: HSG10

Comments

Responses

What are your thoughts on this post?

Loading comments...